Two hill towns, both alike in dignity, in fair Tuscany where we lay our scene. I hoped to have “hard hitting” analysis on the “better” hill town from our recent trip to Tuscany, but our experiences were really apples and oranges. I liked both San Gimignano and Volterra. If I could only recommend one, it might be San Gimignano. No, Volterra. But probably San Gimignano? See, what I mean? I just don’t know. I want to say Volterra, but I feel like it didn’t get a fair shake. Lemme ‘splain.
If you look at the guidebook (Rick Steves’ is our go to), it talks about both towns being nice but Volterra being more untouched by time and San Gimignano being super touristy. San Gimignano is easier to get to from the highway, which likely factors in.
We did San Gimignano in a morning, the morning of the day with the gorgeous weather. We had a nice walk through town. In a way the hill towns are great for kids. Because only local residents can drive, traffic is limited. Definite elevation changes, but almost everything was stroller friendly.
San Gimignano is famous for its surviving towers. There used to be more (70something?). These were a defense mechanism. If you were getting sacked, you climbed up your tower and burnt the stairs.
The town absolutely was touristy. The tiny town has not one, but two torture museums. Buses of tourists pulled up. We passed through many groups visiting from all over the world. I’m not sure we actually saw any locals. It was not uncomfortably crowded, but we weren’t there during peak season. In a way, the touristyness helped us out because things were actually open on a Sunday morning.
After our stroll around town, we had a lovely al fresco lunch at Locanda di Sant’Agostino. It was adjacent to a square and Henry ran around with Alessio, a similarly aged boy who happened to be eating with his parents one table over. Even though we didn’t get to see inside the church or museums, we had a really nice time just experiencing the city. One of those dolce vita moments.
Contrast this to Volterra. We went inside the city three times, but never in the daylight. All three times were chilly. Once it was raining. I hoped to spend a morning in Volterra, but that was the day of ALL THE RAIN so we just kept going post afternoon nap.
Volterra definitely felt less touristy. You didn’t see as many tchotchke shops although there were some. You did feel like you were surrounded by Italians. Real live Italians that actually lived here. But I can’t definitively say that Volterra is less touristy; only that the town is less touristy in the evening, which is what you’d probably expect many places.
We did enjoy some nice food, like our magical night at Enoteca Del Duca. Trattoria da Bado outside of town was amazing. We also had a tasty meal at Don Beta, which was conveniently open closer to when we like to eat. We had a miss on Sunday night where we scrounged for takeout pizza after nothing was open, even things that said they’d be open. *Cough* La Vena di Vino *Cough*
Volterra had sort of a creepy vibe. This could have been heightened by the dark. It felt stark. Craggy. A little desolate. This is where Twilight’s Volturi live. Meyer picked it based on the name, but you could totally see a vampire strolling around the corner at night.
I’m glad we saw both. Volterra was a very intriguing city, but our overall experience in San Gimignano was probably more pleasant for factors outside of Volterra’s control.
So after that imperfect and highly unscientific comparison, if you could visit only one, which one are you leaning toward?